13 Years Later, 2 Major One Tree Hill Fan-Favorites Cast Doubt on Return to Upcoming Reboot

One Tree Hill Reboot Faces Doubts from Lead Actors

There is only one One Tree Hill, but the show feels incomplete without its two main actors. Following the trend of rebooting fan-favorite series such as Buffy the Vampire Slayer, rumors have surfaced about a potential reboot of One Tree Hill, a drama that aired from 2003 to 2012 spanning nine seasons.

Both Buffy and One Tree Hill share similarities beyond their reboot status, including controversies surrounding their creators. Buffy was created by Joss Whedon, who has faced workplace harassment allegations, while One Tree Hill was created by Mark Schwahn. Cast and crew, including lead actors Hilarie Burton Morgan and Danneel Harris Ackles, publicly supported accusations of sexual harassment against Schwahn.

Reboot Announcement and Actor Reactions

The announcement of a reboot for One Tree Hill came in summer 2024, though little information has been revealed since. In a recent People magazine interview for the Sexiest Man Alive feature, Chad Michael Murray and James Lafferty, who portrayed brothers Lucas and Nathan Scott, expressed skepticism about returning.

“We did the show and played those characters for nine years,” Lafferty said. “I’m not sure what the rest of that distance would be.”

The actors recalled their evolving relationship from rivals to close friends but admitted they struggle to envision the show succeeding under current circumstances.

Context of Their Roles and Departure

Summary

The lead stars of One Tree Hill express uncertainty about returning for a reboot amid lingering controversies and personal reflections on their long involvement with the series.

more

Comic Book Resources Comic Book Resources — 2025-11-06