How accurate is Death by Lightning? Exploring facts vs fiction in the latest Netflix drama

How Accurate Is Death by Lightning?

Introduction to the Series

Death by Lightning begins by posing a simple question: “Who is Charles Guiteau?” This sets the tone for Netflix’s new historical mini-series, blending political thriller, tragedy, and a deep focus on historical truth.

Faithfulness to History

Although the series adds creative elements to engage viewers, it largely remains faithful to the real story of President James Garfield’s rise and tragic fall. Some timelines are rearranged, and a few artistic liberties are taken, but the core history stays intact.

Portrayal of James Garfield

Netflix depicts James Garfield (played by Michael Shannon) as a modest man who never aspired to be president. The opening scene shows him building a table, symbolizing his hardworking nature.
This detail is historically accurate: Garfield was indeed more content on his Ohio farm than in Washington.

“Death by Lightning does a remarkable job of staying as faithful as it can to the real story of President James Garfield’s rise and shocking fall.”

“The show starts off with him literally building a table as if it were to remind us that this guy’s hands were made for work and not politics.”

The series offers a cinematic yet authentic glimpse into an important chapter of American history.

Author's Summary

Death by Lightning skillfully balances historical accuracy with narrative drama, offering a gripping yet truthful portrayal of James Garfield’s life and presidency.

Soap Central — 2025-11-07