All Her Fault movie review & film summary (2025) | Roger Ebert

All Her Fault movie review & film summary (2025)

All Her Fault is a tense thriller that grips with sudden shocks like a sinkhole and twists as dangerous as a snake pit. The series begins with a nightmare: Marissa (Sarah Snook) arrives to pick up her son, Milo (Duke McCloud), from a playdate but finds the host mom, Jenny (Dakota Fanning), seemingly unaware. From this moment, the tension only escalates, keeping viewers on edge.

Based on Andrea Mara's novel, the show masterfully builds anxiety from the start. When Milo goes missing, the first act of the eight-episode series is crafted to provoke intense emotion. Every error, glare of blame, and suspicion is depicted in vivid detail, pushing viewers to react strongly.

Unreliable Characters and Shifting Suspicions

The series invites you to question the motives of every character:

Each character is cloaked in ambiguity, making it unclear who is responsible, though it’s certain everyone harbors secrets and guilt.

Intriguing Flashbacks

The storytelling uses flashbacks that span up to ten years, weaving together complex threads. However, these glimpses sometimes reveal less than they conceal, enhancing the show's mysterious and suspenseful atmosphere.

“All Her Fault” is an anxiety-inducing thriller with the sudden drops of a sinkhole and the venomous twists of a snake pit.
“Every mistake, every glare of blame, and suspicion is rendered in vivid detail. You’re supposed to scream at the screen, and you probably will.”

Ultimately, the series engages viewers in a cat-and-mouse game, cleverly ambushing expectations and keeping the mystery alive.

Author’s summary: This tense thriller uses layered flashbacks and complex characters to create a gripping, unpredictable story about misplaced blame and hidden secrets.

more

Roger Ebert Roger Ebert — 2025-11-05